Au Pair Video Interview Tips: How to Really Get to Know a Candidate from 5,000 Miles Away

Finding the right Au Pair for your family involves more than asking a list of interview questions. While learning about a candidate’s childcare experience, personality, and interests is important, how you approach the interview can be just as valuable. A thoughtful interview process helps you build a connection, understand a candidate’s strengths, and decide whether they’re the right fit for your family.

If you’re wondering how to interview Au Pair candidates, these tips will help you make the most of your conversations and feel more confident choosing your future Au Pair.

Plan for Two or Three Conversations

As part of the the 6-step matching process families are required to interview an Au Pair candidate over the phone or through video call at least twice before deciding to match. But, sometimes two interviews may not give you enough time to get to know a candidate. Always plan for plan two or three calls, with each conversation serving a different purpose.

First call: Get to know each other 

Start with a relaxed conversation about your family, your children, and your daily routine. Give the candidate an opportunity to share their background, childcare experience, hobbies, and reasons for becoming an Au Pair. Focus on getting comfortable with one another rather than rushing through a long list of questions. Click the link to learn questions to ask in your first Au Pair interview.

Second call: Discuss childcare and expectations 

Use this conversation to explore the candidate’s experience with children, how they handle challenging situations, and how their childcare approach aligns with your family’s needs. Discuss your schedule, responsibilities, household expectations, and any driving requirements.

Third call: Meet the kids and confirm compatibility

If you feel positive about the candidate, arrange a call that includes your children. This gives everyone another opportunity to connect before making a decision.

Spacing out your conversations also gives you time to reflect, compare candidates, and identify anything you would like to discuss further. You are not limited to the amount of interviews you need to feel comfortable with a candidate. Continue with further interviews until you feel they are the right match.

Include Your Children in a Later Call

Your children will be spending significant time with your Au Pair, so helping them become part of the matching process can be valuable. However, it’s usually best to wait until you have established a connection with the candidate before introducing them.

Keep this call casual and age appropriate. Younger children might enjoy showing the candidate their favorite toy, while older children can talk about their hobbies, school activities, or favorite games.

Pay attention to how the candidate responds. Do they show interest in what your children are saying? Are they patient when a child interrupts or becomes distracted? Do they make an effort to engage with each child?

Remember that children may be shy or hesitant during a video call. A quiet first meeting doesn’t necessarily mean the match isn’t right. Look for opportunities to connect rather than expecting an instant bond.

Parents can bring their child in while interviewing an Au Pair on video call.

Look Beyond Language Fluency to Find Warmth

For many Au Pair candidates, English is a second language. During an Au Pair video interview, a candidate might pause to find the right word, ask you to repeat a question, or struggle to explain an idea. These moments are normal and shouldn’t automatically count against them.

Instead of focusing only on how fluently a candidate speaks, pay attention to how they communicate overall. Do they listen carefully? Do they try to understand your questions? Can they express their thoughts with clarification when needed? Do they show patience, kindness, and genuine interest in your family?

You can also observe nonverbal communication, including facial expressions, tone of voice, and responsiveness. These cues may help you understand a candidate’s warmth and personality, although video calls and cultural differences can sometimes make them harder to interpret.

English communication is important, especially for childcare and safety. Evaluate it fairly alongside the candidate’s other qualifications, rather than confusing nervousness with a lack of ability.

Give Candidates Time to Ask Questions

An interview should be a two way conversation. Your Au Pair candidate is also deciding whether your family, lifestyle, and expectations are right for them.

Make time for candidates to ask about your children’s routines, living arrangements, local community, schedule, and family expectations. Encourage honest questions and give clear answers, even when discussing challenging parts of your routine.

A candidate who asks thoughtful questions may be demonstrating that they take the commitment seriously. Avoid interpreting a quiet candidate as uninterested simply because they don’t immediately ask many questions. Some candidates may need time to think or feel more comfortable asking questions during a follow up call.

Being open and transparent helps establish trust before the match begins.

Au Pair candidate participating in an Au Pair video interview with a prospective Host Family to discuss childcare experience and family expectations

Be Considerate of Time Zones

Many Au Pair candidates are interviewing from another country, so scheduling requires a little extra planning. Before arranging a call, check the time difference and confirm the meeting time with the candidate.

Whenever possible, choose a reasonable hour for both parties. Be mindful that a candidate may be joining after a full day of responsibilities or during a time that is inconvenient locally.

Share the video call details in advance, confirm the appointment, and let the candidate know if you need to reschedule. If someone is late or appears tired, consider the circumstances before drawing conclusions about their interest or professionalism.

Small gestures of consideration can help create a positive first impression on both sides.

Avoid Common Interviewing Mistakes

When interviewing an Au Pair, it’s easy to let first impressions influence your decision. Keep these common judgment errors in mind:

  • Penalizing nervous English: Give candidates time to settle in and clarify their answers before judging their communication skills.

  • Overvaluing charisma: A confident, outgoing candidate isn’t automatically a better caregiver than someone who is quieter or more reserved.

  • Making decisions too quickly: Use multiple conversations to assess compatibility instead of relying on one strong or weak first impression.

  • Ignoring practical expectations: A friendly connection matters, but schedules, childcare responsibilities, driving needs, and household rules must also align.

  • Doing all the talking: Leave space for candidates to share their experiences, express concerns, and ask questions.

The best Au Pair matching tips balance personal connection with practical considerations. Look for a candidate whose skills, values, communication style, and expectations fit your family’s needs.

Use a Scorecard to Compare Candidates

After each interview, write down your impressions while the conversation is still fresh. A simple scorecard helps you compare candidates consistently and reduces the chance that one memorable moment will overshadow other important qualities.

Rate each category from 1 to 5, with 1 representing a poor fit and 5 representing an excellent fit.

Add notes about each candidate’s strengths, any concerns, and questions to revisit during your next call. Consider which qualities are essential for your family and which can develop with time and support.

Ultimately, the goal isn’t to find the candidate who gives the most impressive interview. It’s to find someone who can provide responsible, caring childcare while becoming a positive part of your family’s daily life.

With thoughtful conversations, fair evaluations, and a consistent scorecard, you’ll be better prepared to choose an au pair who feels like the right match for your family.

Ready to Find Your Perfect Au Pair Match?

Choosing an Au Pair is an important decision, and taking the time to get to know your candidates can make all the difference. By asking thoughtful questions, creating opportunities for genuine connection, and evaluating each candidate beyond first impressions, you can find someone who fits your family’s childcare needs and lifestyle.

Remember, the best match is about more than experience or a great interview. It’s about building a relationship based on trust, communication, and shared expectations. Take your time, trust the process, and focus on finding an Au Pair who will help your family thrive while creating meaningful cultural exchange experiences along the way.